Showing posts with label gender. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gender. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

"Women's Economic Engagement & the Europe 2020 Agenda" - A Reflection

Image - Merrion Street.ie


Women's Economic Engagement and the Europe 2020 Agenda.  A statement of intent?

As discussed many times on this blog over the past few years - the 'old chestnut'  or 'groundhog day' sentiment -  surrounding re-balancing the gender  issue continues to rumble on.  In light of this fact, I was delighted to have the opportunity to attend a conference which appeared to set out a real statement of intent insofar as addressing the importance of balance and instating equality in the economic context.

I wasn't disappointed.  Though there may have been a little repetition in the content of various speakers' presentations - by and large - the detail offered a pan-European view on the challenges, opportunities and key policy levers available to governments in supporting, enhancing and developing women's economic engagement.

The Core Issues | Women's Economic Independence

Unsurprisingly - the core issues remain the same.  Women are more educated than their male counterparts ["we employ least those we educate most" Minister Kathleen Lynch].  Women do not enjoy equal pay, with a 17% total gender pay gap in existence across Europe.  Women often suffer negative career impacts as a result of parenthood.  Only 30% of start-ups are female and over 1/3 of employed women work part-time, a choice which in the main, is to facilitate family-centric responsibilities.  Based on the most recent available detail [ from the EEN] only 15-18% of established entrepreneurs in Ireland are women.

As I said, not entirely surprising news.  However, when painted in the stark light of this series of presentations - it certainly highlighted the need for real tangible action.

The Potential Answers | A Way Forward

Whilst challenges are clear, many speakers over the course of the conference pointed to the need for real solutions that can be applied through policy levers and supports.  A new, more modern approach to childcare supports [potentially modeled on Nordic and Icelandic provisions], and the reduction of fiscal disincentives were hailed as key factors in supporting women's economic engagement.

So, what does this all translate into - in real terms? Undoubtedly, balance is required - and, as Avivah Wittenberg-Cox stated "we need to re-brand this story"... I couldn't agree more.  It's about time we changed the name of this debate, and examined it in the context of what it really is - an issue for society not just women.  As hot a topic the gender quota issue is - there are genuine merits in policy levers - and though some may not agree with the notion of direct intervention, it is fair to say that oftentimes it is the only way of effecting real change.  In the context of the broader economic engagement of women, across Europe - can we learn more about what's not working? 

One thing which clearly isn't working is the non-conducive work environment; across private and public sectors, politics and entrepreneurship.  If so many feel their chances of retaining prospects after parenthood, developing their career or at least, being paid the same as their male comparator, are at best, limited - then, what's to attract broader engagement?

The Realities | What's Next?

I'm only too aware that there are the A-students in private sector companies, putting their policies where the 'mouth' is, so-to-speak... [Vodafone, P&G, Sodexho all represented at the conference].  However, cultivating more awareness - again, societally - is paramount to meaningful change.  With the European Commission target set at 75% female labour market participation by 2020, policy-makers and government agencies had better get their 'thinking caps' on - and fast.  As mentioned by Dr. Daniela Bankier of the European Commission's DG Justice - if meaningful change doesn't happen, this target will not be met.  As it stands, we're not on target.  To quote the aforementioned speaker "equality between men and women is a fundamental right and an economic neccessity".  This comment was roundly resonated by Mikael Gustafsson, MEP when he commented that "no society can afford to waste half its talent".

The optimist in me hopes that - yes, the 75% target can be achieved.  Meaningfully. The reality? I'm not so sure.  There are real, embedded, cultural challenges that Ireland has yet to overcome - in our attitudes, viewpoints and beliefs.  While some negative stances may be worn away over time, there are many rekindled through new generations saddled with inherited, jaundiced outlooks.  These are challenges shared by our European colleagues, undoubtedly.

So what can we do? For those of us with representative or supportive roles - it's key to reach out to those who need our help.  More importantly, we can take action and make change happen... not least of all, by activating the authorities, agencies and policy-makers to build measures, programmes and plans which will harness and support the potential of women in all areas of the economy.

The stats are clear and indisputable: we need to move past analysis paralysis.  It's time for action.

***

Gender Quotas and Binders Full of Women... the Perception Issue  |  The Female Entrepreneurship Q

Monday, November 12, 2012

Gender Quotas and Binders Full of Women... the Perception Issue

Photo: International Business Times

So I reckoned that this title would generate quite a few titters of amusement, not least of all because ones' intention is not so diametrically opposed to the other as it might seem!

Over the last few years, I've been engaged in projects which - in one way or another - were focused on supporting, harnessing and developing female entrepreneurship.  Some have been voluntary; others have been in the course of my work with clients; the principal rationale which united them all? An attempt to make a difference.

Returning to my somewhat comedic blog-title, I'm consciously aware of the various bids of late by Governments at home and abroad, as well as those in the social entrepreneurship 'space' to do their bit [and it should be noted that many are making serious headway] to enhance the visibility of politics, decision-making and entrepreneurship as real career options for women.

The reality, however, is that perception is still an issue.  I don't say this as a throwaway comment, but one which I encounter every day, in conversation with colleagues I respect and admire, as well as those who I may have battled in the past.

What do I mean? Perception, as is often said, is reality.  In this instance,  perception of female-centric platforms and programmes can be held as: "YET another measure - more of the same" or "more boring on about gender equality again".  Talking to Focus SME's Kehlan Kirwan last Saturday morning for the Small Business Show, I mentioned a regular perception I come across - that female-focused programmes are often perceived as 'sexist' .  I might add, that this perception is coming from those who should know better, some are [shock-horror] women and others are entrepreneurs.

Are you not getting it folks? If we don't support the non-engaged, they never will engage? For entrepreneurship alone, women are still behind, with less than 50% of start-ups in 2010 being female-led and only 15-18% of leadership positions in entrepreneurship being held by women [Enterprise Europe Network - 2010]

The fact is, the change is still a-coming, and it's taking longer than we thought.  Last year, I wrote a short, sharp post inspired by Moira Forbes, and her view that there was a sense of "Groundhog Day" about the gender issue.  To be honest, as I sit here, 21 months later, I'm feeling a sense of déjà-vu myself.  

The other perception issue lies with our 'end users' - women who are still afraid to put their heads above the parapet for fear of many things, not least of all, not being taken seriously.  

To speak from my own experience, I certainly had many moments of absolute fear - not least of all, those moments when I realised I was doing battle on a playing field where I was about twenty years younger and a different gender to my colleagues.  Still, one must carry on regardless, even when one is absolutely terrified.  

What made me different? What gave me the steel in my spine at times when I could have bent-double? A network; role models; and most of all, an unerring need to continue on, fueled by support and belief.  

So, in sum - for those of us seeking to entice, support and develop the potential of women in politics, enterprise, decision-making or other walks - we need to remember the tenets borne-out by the European Commission [Enterprise Europe Network] in recent years:
  • Visibility of role models;
  • Access to tailored training and mentoring;
  • Networks focused on mutual support.
.. and finally, when we've achieved that, a little cultural, attitudinal change wouldn't go amiss.  But that's a whole other story [blog post].